As Americans mark Tax Day, new polling data highlighted on CNN suggests President Donald Trump is facing significant skepticism from the public — particularly independents — on one of the most critical issues of his agenda: taxes.
During a Wednesday morning segment, CNN’s John Berman and data analyst Harry Enten examined the latest numbers, revealing a sharp shift compared to Trump’s first term. According to Enten, Trump’s net approval rating on taxes has dropped dramatically, falling from a positive position in 2018 to deeply negative territory today.
Back in 2018, shortly after a major tax cut was passed, Trump’s approval on taxes stood slightly above water at plus two points. Now, that figure has fallen to minus 28 points, marking a 30-point swing. The decline suggests that whatever political momentum once accompanied tax policy has faded, at least in the eyes of many voters.
The numbers are even more striking among independents, a group often seen as decisive in national elections. According to the polling discussed on air, Trump is now 58 points underwater with independents on the issue of taxes. For a voting bloc that frequently determines electoral outcomes, such a gap presents a serious political challenge.
Enten noted that despite the administration’s push for its so-called “One Big Beautiful Bill Act,” the public response has been far from enthusiastic. In fact, the legislation itself carries a negative approval rating, sitting 20 points underwater overall. Among independents, the numbers are even worse, with the bill registering 41 points underwater.
Berman pointed out that the tax measure represents a signature legislative achievement heading into the midterm election season, making its reception all the more significant. The polling suggests that, at least for now, many Americans are not embracing the policy as intended.
The data underscores a broader issue that has persisted for Trump: difficulty winning over independent voters. While partisan support often remains entrenched, independents appear less convinced, particularly when it comes to complex economic policies that directly affect household finances.
At the same time, the debate over taxes reflects deeper questions about government priorities and economic direction. Supporters of tax cuts often argue they are essential for growth and competitiveness, while critics question whether the benefits are widely felt. The polling does not delve into those arguments directly, but it does make clear that the administration’s message is not fully landing with a large portion of the electorate.
As the country moves deeper into an election cycle, these numbers could take on added importance. Tax policy, long a cornerstone of political debate, remains a powerful lens through which voters evaluate leadership.
For now, the polling paints a sobering picture for the administration. Even as Washington continues to push forward on legislation, the response from voters — especially those outside the partisan base — suggests that winning the argument may be just as difficult as passing the law.
